Skip to main content

A Month w/out Murder in Brick City

So, I was perusing the internet today and stumbled upon a series of articles that people may or may not have heard about.  Apparently, the city of Newark, NJ, celebrated a month without murder last April, 2010.  I guess this hadn't happened since the late 1960s.  I was astonished when I read this.  I've heard plenty of bad stories about "Brick City" from close friends who have grown up there or lived there, but for some reason this statistic and the news coverage around it floored me.  What's it like to live in a place where a month without murder makes the news?  

Dilapidated projects in Newark, NJ
 Then, I began digging around on one my favorite wikipedia sites: The US Cities by Crime Rate page.  This is a great page, if you're interested.  Some people took the time to compile the FBI's Uniform Crime Stats and organized them into a table that you can manipulate to your liking.  So, for instance, if you were curious, you could find out that Toledo, Ohio lead the nation in Arson in 2009, or that in the same year, Oakland, CA lead the nation in motor vehicle theft. 

After a few clicks and some scrolling, I discovered something kind of curious about Newark's violent crime rates.  In 2009, Newark ranked in the top 5 cities with the highest murder rate (250k and above).  However, in many other violent crime categories, Newark ranked significantly lower.  For instance, Newark ranked 58th in forcible rape, 17th in robbery, and 36th in aggravated assault.  It's interesting that St. Louis, one of Newark's "peer cities" in terms of size and murder rate, seems to be much more consistently violent across all categories: St. Louis is tied for 2nd in murder, 8th in forcible rape, 2nd in robbery, and 2nd in aggravated assault. 

What explains these disparities across different violent crime rates in Newark?  My best guess is that people are reporting violent crime at a much lower rate in Newark than in places like St. Louis.  Sociologists and criminologists have long known that rape, robbery, and aggravated assault are some of the most under-reported violent crimes out there.  Unlike dead bodies, victims of rape, robbery, and violent assaults (that don't require extended hospitalization or medical care), often go unnoticed and unreported.  This has long been one of the shortcomings in Uniform Crime Report Data; it's entirely based on crimes that are reported and documented by the police.  I understand that this is one of the best measurements out there, but it doesn't provide a really good way around under-reporting of violent crime.  Then, again, maybe there's something unique about Newark's violent crime problem, right?

I guess I'm just wondering if is this a reporting/documenting crime problem, or something unique about the city of Newark?

If you're interested, here's a great song, "Brick City Mashin'" by Redman...

Comments

  1. AnonymousJune 28, 2011 at 10:14 AM

    Yes, this is quite a puzzle, definitely worth some Rutgers' student's time to go out and write a thesis, even a dissertation on. Have you read Mark Kleiman's new book? When Brute Force Fails. He presents similar cases, some based on David Kennedy's (John Jay, CUNY)? It could've been spontaneous ceasefire, but unlikely. I do believe that more police, especially with strategy in mind, can halt (or move) crime, at least for a while. If you're really interested, I'd see what I could find on police enforcement strategy (no doubt proactive, which requires profiling by definition, but I'm bracketing the political dimension here). Interesting. Update if you learn more...

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Long Shadow of Gun Violence (In Loving Memory of Bette Clark)

I met Bette and her oldest son, Joey, during a death penalty trial in Center City.  It was the sentencing phase for the two men who killed her youngest son, Timmy, who was gunned down execution-style when he was 15. Caroline, an advocate with the Families of Murder Victims, introduced us.  "Bette, this is Jooyoung.  He's a researcher and wants to interview you."  Joey sized me up and seemed protective of his mom, who had already been through so much.  Her eyes were red from crying, so I said, "I'm really sorry to hear about what happened." She smiled a little and said in her Tacony accent, "Thank you. It's been such a long day.  But, call me whenever, sure." I spent the next day with Bette and her family at the courthouse and visited them weekly over the next year.  I hadn't planned on following the families of murder victims, but my ongoing research in Philly had pushed me in this direction.   While getting to know gunshot...
8 comments
Read more

The Existential Fall Out after Newtown

The Existential Fall Out after Newtown I have a heavy heart tonight.  My thoughts and prayers are with the families of Newtown.  The Newtown shooting is a terrible tragedy. It has reminded me of lessons learned while studying the families of murder victims.  For the past 2 years, I have been researching the everyday lives of families who lose someone in a murder.  This has been difficult—and often heartbreaking—research.  I have spent many nights thinking about how much I take my family, friends, and other people in my life for granted.   I think about the mothers, fathers, grandparents, aunts, uncles, and siblings whose first and last thoughts of each day are of the person they loved and lost. The things that I have seen and the stories that I have collected have left a deep and permanent mark on my soul. Amongst the many thoughts swirling around in my head, I keep returning to a t...
8 comments
Read more

Bath Salts and Ultra Violence?

During the past couple weeks, I've come across shocking stories of people who become ultra violent after ingesting hallucinogens.  These stories are a sharp contrast to the likes of Ken Kesey and the Merry Pranksters.  The two stories are something closer to scenes from Texas Chainsaw Massacre. For example, the Internet is filled with stories of Rudy Eugene, a man who was discovered eating another man's face in Miami.  Reports are linking his ultra-violent behavior to "bath salts," a mostly legal synthetic compound that is said to produce a wide array of intense hallucinogenic results in users after ingestion. After being summoned by a fellow motorist, police officers shot and killed Eugene who allegedly growled at officers and continued chewing on the victim's facial flesh until he was shot and killed.  In the media frenzy, Eugene is being called everything from a crazed "zombie" to a cannibal on the Internet. Ronald Poppo (victim) and Rudy Eugene...
5 comments
Read more