Haunted by Gun Violence

The New York Times reported today that homicides in Chicago are down. Data shows that year-to-date homicides have declined by 34%. This is the kind of crime drop that has public officials, police, and news reporters cheering. Statistically speaking, Chicago and other major cities are "safer" places than they were a year ago.

But, stats don't easily map onto the lived experiences of community members in these "hot spots" of crime. People living in areas with long histories of gun violence don't suddenly "feel safe" because politicians, police, and newspapers say so. Many are haunted by memories of family members, friends, and random acquaintances who have been gunned down in their backyards, on their stoops, and on corners in their neighborhoods. These memories aren't easily washed away by larger statistical trends in violence. They linger on in the minds of community members. They become key events that shape how community members make sense of their own lives and safety in the world.

Photo of North Philly mural from Carlos Javier Ortiz, 2008

Many of the folks that I've met throughout my fieldwork live in places that see similar annual fluctuations in crime. I always found it interesting how community members continued to be gripped by fear and continued to live their lives as if violence could happen during times when local politicians and police were celebrating drops in violent crime. Their everyday lives seemed unchanged by the public enthusiasm around improved crime fighting. One of the residents in the NY Times article captured this lingering fear best, "If you ask me, nothing has changed. I'm still scared to let the kids play in front of the house."

While year-to-year crime drops give everyone hope that they are making a dent on crime, we should remember that feeling "safe" and being "safe" are two different things. Making people "feel safe" is an elusive thing that requires a different kind of intervention. Simply increasing the number of police officers on the streets, or changing their tactics aren't likely to improve feelings of safety on the ground. I'm not sure what this would look like, but it's worth asking: What kinds of things might help community members "feel safe"?

Comments

The Long Shadow of Gun Violence (In Loving Memory of Bette Clark)

I met Bette and her oldest son, Joey, during a death penalty trial in Center City. It was the sentencing phase for the two men who killed her youngest son, Timmy, who was gunned down execution-style when he was 15. Caroline, an advocate with the Families of Murder Victims, introduced us. "Bette, this is Jooyoung. He's a researcher and wants to interview you." Joey sized me up and seemed protective of his mom, who had already been through so much. Her eyes were red from crying, so I said, "I'm really sorry to hear about what happened." She smiled a little and said in her Tacony accent, "Thank you. It's been such a long day. But, call me whenever, sure." I spent the next day with Bette and her family at the courthouse and visited them weekly over the next year. I hadn't planned on following the families of murder victims, but my ongoing research in Philly had pushed me in this direction. While getting to know gunshot

The Existential Fall Out after Newtown

The Existential Fall Out after Newtown I have a heavy heart tonight. My thoughts and prayers are with the families of Newtown. The Newtown shooting is a terrible tragedy. It has reminded me of lessons learned while studying the families of murder victims. For the past 2 years, I have been researching the everyday lives of families who lose someone in a murder. This has been difficult—and often heartbreaking—research. I have spent many nights thinking about how much I take my family, friends, and other people in my life for granted. I think about the mothers, fathers, grandparents, aunts, uncles, and siblings whose first and last thoughts of each day are of the person they loved and lost. The things that I have seen and the stories that I have collected have left a deep and permanent mark on my soul. Amongst the many thoughts swirling around in my head, I keep returning to a troubling “double standard” that we

Bas Rutten's Punk Payback: How (Not) to Act During a Robbery

El Guapo I love Bas "El Guapo" Rutten. The Dutchman was a former UFC Heavyweight Champion, 3-time King of Pancrase, and an all-around badass. Following his illustrious fighting career, he transitioned into MMA commentary. I've found his commentary insightful and think that he comes across as a very humble and approachable person. Recently, I learned that Fuel TV was producing a show for Rutten called "Punk Payback." I immediately thought that the show would be a spin-off of MTV's "Bully Beatdown," a show in which professional MMA fighters confront and beat up bullies. To me, this would make sense: Bas Rutten was bullied when he was younger and openly talks about developing self confidence/awareness through the martial arts. I just watched a 10-minute clip of Punk Payback and am surprised to report that it isn't this kind of show. Instead, the episode I saw featured Rutten providing colorful commentary on how to resist/disarm armed

Positive Sociology

Search This Blog